The infographic below is a snapshot of the legislative history of Section 90(4) and 90(5) of IT Act, 1961. It provides a summary view of the Income Tax Department’s attempt to include a stringent condition for a non-resident assessee to claim DTAA benefits. The condition, simply stated, was that a TRC issued by a contracting state is a necessary but not a sufficient condition to claim DTAA benefits. It was supposed to allow the Indian income tax authorities to go behind the TRC issued by another state.
The importance and relevance of the legislative history of the aforesaid provisions can be better understood by reading this and this in the wake of Delhi High Court’s decision involving tax benefits under the India-Singapore DTAA. An appeal against the decision is pending before the Supreme Court at the time of publishing this infographic.