Penalties for e-way bills cannot be imposed in absence of Mens Rea: Allahabad HC
The Allahabad High Court in a recent judgment took the view that the GST Department cannot impose a penalty on taxpayers – under Section 129(3), CGST Act, 2017 – for not possessing e-way bills in the absence of… Read More »Penalties for e-way bills cannot be imposed in absence of Mens Rea: Allahabad HC
Post-Supply Discounts Cannot be Included in Transaction Value: Madras HC
The Madras High Court recently observed that post-supply discounts offered by a supplier to the recipient cannot be included in the transaction value/value of supply for levying GST. The High Court distinguished between subsidy offered by a… Read More »Post-Supply Discounts Cannot be Included in Transaction Value: Madras HC
Supply of Vouchers and GST: Three Decisions and a Defensible Conclusion
This article focuses on the issue raised by M/s Kalyan Jewellers Limited (‘Kalyan Jewellers’) as regards the pre-paid instruments (‘PPI’)/vouchers issued by them to their customers. The claim of Kalyan Jewellers before the Advance Authority (‘AAR’), Appellate body… Read More »Supply of Vouchers and GST: Three Decisions and a Defensible Conclusion
NAA is Constitutional, Individual Orders Can be Challenged on Merits: Delhi HC
Introduction This post focuses on the Delhi High Court’s recent judgment upholding the constitutionality of NAA, a statutory body established under Section 171, CGST Act, 2017. I’ve examined the working of NAA in detail here and here, where I’ve highlighted… Read More »NAA is Constitutional, Individual Orders Can be Challenged on Merits: Delhi HC
Whose Money is it? Madras HC Says Deposit of Cash Amounts to Payment of GST
The Madras High Court, in a recent decision, observed that the money in Electronic Cash Ledger (‘ECL’) of the taxpayer belongs to the exchequer since the money was deposited in the name of the exchequer in… Read More »Whose Money is it? Madras HC Says Deposit of Cash Amounts to Payment of GST
Section 16, CGST Act is Constitutional: Kerala HC
The Kerala High Court recently[1] dismissed a taxpayer’s challenge that Section 16(2)(c) and Rule 36(4) of CGST Rules, 2017 were violative of Article 14 and unconstitutional. The High Court ruled that the taxpayer’s challenge was vague, and the impugned provisions did… Read More »Section 16, CGST Act is Constitutional: Kerala HC
Jharkhand HC Allows State Authorities to Continue Proceedings, Rejects DGGI’S Arguments on Nationwide Fake ITC Fraud
The Jharkhand High Court recently adjudicated a writ petition where the petitioner had argued that only the authority which had initiated the entire process of investigation can complete the modalities and any subsequent actions by other authorities… Read More »Jharkhand HC Allows State Authorities to Continue Proceedings, Rejects DGGI’S Arguments on Nationwide Fake ITC Fraud
An Ambiguous Circular: Is Electricity Indirectly under GST?
On 31.10.2023, CBIC issued a Circular clarifying the applicability of GST on certain services. The Circular, inter alia, clarified one issue which is the focus of this article. The issue, as framed by the Circular, was: Whether GST… Read More »An Ambiguous Circular: Is Electricity Indirectly under GST?